Skip to content
  1. Mother's Day Sale! Use Code LOVEMOM15 for 15% Off Entire Order + FREE Shipping – Limited Time Only!
Chunky Peanut Butter Cookies - 6 Count
Chunky Peanut Butter Cookies - 6 Count
Chunky Peanut Butter Cookies - 6 Count
Chunky Peanut Butter Cookies - 6 Count

  • Free Shipping

Chunky Peanut Butter Cookies - 6 Count

Sale price $36.96 Regular price $39.95
Save 7%

Shipping calculated at checkout

Spend $0 to get free shipping Congratulations! You get free shipping.

Delivery typically takes 1-3 business days.
  • Nationwide Shipping
  • Made From Scratch in Texas
  • Trusted Reviews
  • No Prep Needed
  • Gorgeous Gift Box

Frequently Bundled Together

Best Mini Pies Delivered to Your Doorstep as a gift or to treat yourself Best mini pies shipped nationwide from Pie in the Sky Pie Co. in Texas

4” Mini Pies Sampler - 4 Pack

$49.95
best apple pie shipped nationwide and delivered to your door. apple pie delivery and shipped nationwide

Apple Pie

$44.95
Best Blueberry Pie Delivered to Your Doorstep blueberry pie shipped nationwide and delivered to your doorstep

Blueberry Pie

$44.95
Best Bumbleberry Pie Delivered to Your Doorstep bumbleberry pie shipped nationwide and delivered to your doorstep

Bumbleberry Pie

$44.95
Best Vanilla Pecan Pie Delivered to Your Doorstep As A Gift or For Yourself buttermilk pecan pie shipped nationwide and delivered to your doorstep

Buttermilk Pecan Pie

$44.95
Best Cherry Pie Delivered to Your Doorstep as a gift or to treat yourself cherry pie shipped nationwide and delivered to your doorstep

Cherry Pie

$44.95
Fresh Pies Delivered to Your Doorstep from Pie in the Sky Pie Co Best Chocolate Truffle Pie Delivered to Your Doorstep as a gift or to treat yourself

Chocolate Truffle Pie

$44.95
Best Mississippi Mud Pie Delivered to Your Doorstep as a gift or to treat yourself chocolate pie shipped nationwide and delivered to your doorstep

Mississippi Mud Pie

$44.95
Best Pecan Pie Delivered to Your Doorstep as a gift or to treat yourself pecan pie shipped nationwide and delivered to your doorstep

Pecan Pie

$44.95
Best Strawberry Rhubarb Pie Delivered to Your Doorstep as a gift or to treat yourself strawberry rhubarb pie shipped nationwide and delivered to your doorstep

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

$44.95

Packed with bold, nutty flavor and a soft, melt-in-your-mouth texture, our Peanut Butter Cookies are a bakery classic. We bake them fresh in Texas and ship them in 6-packs nationwide. Rich, nostalgic, and totally addictive — one bite and you’ll know why it’s a best-seller.

Freshness & Storage

  • We bake every cookie fresh daily at our Texas bakery ensuring it’s delivered to you at its peak freshness and flavor.
  • Please eat or freeze your cookieswithin three days from the time you receive it. Refrigerate during that time.
  • Freezer life is up to 3 months. To defrost, place in refrigerator or set on countertop. To enjoy hot, place in the oven until warm throughout.

Shipping & Delivery

Under ideal conditions, delivery is typically within 1 to 3 business days. All orders will be shipped via UPS. To ensure your pies and baked products are as fresh as possible, pies are only shipped Monday - Thursday due to the time in transit.

We need one day to process your order. Orders received after 9 am on Thursday will be shipped on Monday. You will receive a tracking number in your email when your order has been processed.

Allergens

Please be aware that this product is manufactured in a facility that uses Wheat Flour, Eggs, Soybean Oil, Milk and Tree Nuts.
About Us

Our journey began in 1996 in Texas, selling homemade pies out of our parents’ gas station. By 2005, we opened our first bakery in Texas, turning our passion into a thriving business. As demand grew, we've grown into a nationwide wholesaler and now ship our handcrafted pies straight to your door. Whether you’re celebrating or just craving something sweet, we’re here to bring you a taste of home—one pie at a time.